Selection Bias

Conflating a certification, license, or degree with actual ability is easy. We look on the wall, see the certificate, and assume that the paper implies ability. These days we especially pay attention to online reviews. A glowing five-star review with a paragraph of praise is worth money. If only reality was so easily aligned with glamour. Use of other criteria seems to vanish when compared to just a few simple guides.

A cross-cultural study done years ago looked at top-rated medical practitioners in various cultures, not just western ones. The finding boiled down to a few basic features.

Across cultures, there seemed to be three common traits between the folk practitioner in Mexico, Papua, and the MD in New York. Things they had in common? All possessed:

  1. a very effective bedside manner
  2.  expensive fees
  3. a piece of impressive technology that they used in treatment.

So, note that I described the practitioners as top-rated, not necessarily effective. 

But I don’t want to pick on the medical profession. Unfortunately, we apply the same criteria to selecting services from financial advisors and other “professionals.” Related standards select schools, certification programs, and consumer products.

Here’s my evaluation. In a world where there were never so many research tools available for the considerate and intelligent user to manipulate, There was never so much lousy research. So what do people base their analysis on? I suspect that it’s Yelp reviews – how effective the bedside manner was; Cost – is it expensive and therefore better; and how unique the technology is.

So here is my challenge. Broaden your evaluations. Take into account more factors.

It’s a challenge and may take more time, but hey…you’re not chicken…are you?

3 Replies to “Selection Bias”

  1. Ha, great examples! I had one of my over 90 year patients come in once saying, I think I have influenza. I though so too, because she had a fever and a fast heart rate and the history fitted. I called the emergency room to let them know I was sending her (from less then a mile away). The ER doctor says, “Did you do an ECG?” I said, “Oh, no, I don’t have an ECG machine.” “WHAT?!?” he says, “You don’t have an ECG machine! You can’t have a clinic without one!” “Oh, it’s in the shop right now,” I assured him. I did have an AED, on long term loan from a retired flight surgeon. My over 90 year old went to the ER and as she and I both thought, she had influenza, needed oxygen, and was not having a heart attack. I ran my solo clinic for ten years and the best piece of “equipment” I had was my ears and eyes and brain and stethoscope.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The very best physicians in medieval Spain relied on two primary diagnostic tools the pulse, which they divided and carefully analyzed, and the glass urine bottle, because analyzing the color, turbidity, and sedimentation of urine was considered to be one of the best diagnostic tools they had.
      They were dependent on their eyes, ears, nose, brain, and of course the depth of their diagnostic experience. The technology is great, but often as you point out it’s the basic built-in tools that make the correct diagnosis.

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.

Selkie

Selkie is a Kadey Krogen 39 owned by Tad and Libbie Sheldon

My Vivid Blog

."Vivid" is my handy, all-purpose word, and this is my handy, all-purpose blog.

claytoonz

Nationally Syndicated Editorial Cartoonist

By Shreyas

Photographs, Films and Stories

Babsje Heron

Great Blue Herons: A study in patience and grace

Under the mask..

..all this.

Gargoyles and Grotesques

Don't Look Up! Something May Be Watching You...

Paul's Wonderful World of Color

The Color Photography of Paul Szlosek

The Renaissance Mathematicus

Just another WordPress.com weblog

Sammi Cox

Author Aspiring

Stephen Fielding Images

Views of the natural environment & climate change

Family Matters

I'm Victoria Stuart, a poet committed to love's transmission.

Charlie Sheldon's STORIES MADE US HUMAN

STORIES ABOUT THE MOUNTAINS, THE SEA, AND ANCIENT TRUTH

My Two Bits

My thoughts and ideas about life, cats, and whatever else I think about

WEGGIEBOY'S BLOG

Andy and I miss Dougy

Jalsails's Blog

Spontaneous Connections During Tidal Times

....on pets and prisoners.....

food for the body; food for the soul

%d bloggers like this: